RSS

Tag Archives: Arab Springs

The Summit’ offers Italian insights into Egypt’s revolution by Heba Afify

As the brutality of police and military forces against protesters has increased across the Arab World over the past year, it’s easy to forget that the region does not have a monopoly over this violence.

“The Summit,” an investigative documentary screened last week at the Berlin International Film Festival, reminds us that while the frequency of crackdowns varies in different parts of the world, when security forces decide to attack, they often do so with a similar level of brutality.

In the film, Italian journalists Franco Fracassi and Camillo De Marco dissect the brutal security crackdown against anti-globalization protests at the G8 summit in Gonoa, Italy in June 2001. The police attack left one dead and hundreds of protesters severely injured.

“The Summit” offers rare insight into a seemingly out-of-place human rights breach that has somehow failed to leave a mark on the global consciousness. Fracassi and De Marco succeed in fully reconstructing the incident, which took place over a decade ago, using firsthand accounts by protesters, chilling documentary footage, released police tapes and emergency calls from horrified eyewitnesses.

The filmmakers, along with an investigator, sifted through hours of documentary footage that show a very different narrative from the official one propagated by local police forces.

Still, some parts of the film are a bit cliché, seemingly influenced by mainstream detective shows. For example, one scene shows the detective-looking narrator sitting in an interrogation room, facing the camera with a raised eyebrow, questioning the “official” version of the story.

In an interview with Egypt Independent after the film screening in Berlin, Fracassi commented on some of the staggering similarities between the police tactics shown in the film and those used by police and military forces in Egypt. These similarities suggest that police forces in both countries were trained in the same place — the US — says Fracassi.

While the identity of the thugs who are believed to “infiltrate” or attack protesters in Egypt, often dubbed “the third party,” remains unknown, “The Summit” clearly identifies a vandalism group, called the Black Bloc, as Italy’s “third party.”

It seems that deploying violent groups to justify attacks on peaceful protesters is a standard tactic in the police manual.

Eyewitnesses in the film testify to seeing Black Bloc members — or “thugs” as they are often described in the Egyptian media — instigating violence, and then hiding behind the police lines as security forces attack peaceful protesters.

Especially resonant with the Egyptian experience are the tapes of emergency calls featured in the film, which reveal that operators responded to frantic callers reporting criminal acts by saying they have orders not to intervene.

Eyewitnesses in “The Summit” also discuss how deploying violent gangs during protests was meant to place the blame for violence and vandalism on protesters and turn the public against them. Revolutionaries in Egypt have been facing similar accusations throughout the past year.

In the testimonials shown in “The Summit,” people describe police brutality as animal-like, giving off a strong stench of testosterone and sweat — a description that could easily be used to describe the Egyptian military forces dragging female protesters by their hair and beating the bodies of dead protesters before throwing them on piles of garbage on street corners.

In Egypt, many activists subjected to torture and serious injury in clashes with security forces are back on the streets, protesting. The Gonoa attack, however, seems to have left much deeper scars on its victims, who were taken by surprise as they were used to police forces protecting protests, not attacking them.

Fracassi, who is both the director of “The Summit” and a subject in the film, as he was attacked by police in Genoa while working as a journalist, says that making the film was part of his healing process. Fracassi and other victims said that, a decade later, it was still difficult for them to watch the incident or read about it, and their voices shook up as they recounted their ordeals.

“The Summit” thoroughly investigates an incident that mirrors the periodic use of violence against protesters in Egypt, and possibly offers Egyptians clues to find the truth about the events of the past year.

©2012 Heba Afify

 
Leave a comment

Posted by on February 24, 2012 in Art as a matter of life

 

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Egyptian film star sentenced for insulting Islam

The Arab world’s most famous comic actor, Adel Imam, has received a three-month jail sentence for insulting Islam in films and plays, a court document showed on Thursday.

Imam, who has frequently poked fun at authorities and politicians of all colors during a 40-year career, has one month to appeal the sentence and will remain out of jail until the appeal process is concluded.

The sentence Wednesday evening came weeks after Islamists swept most seats in parliamentary elections. The case was brought by Asran Mansour, a lawyer with ties to Islamist groups, and had languished in court for months, judicial sources said.

Mansour accused the actor of offending Islam and its symbols, including beards and the Jilbab, a loose-fitting garment worn by some Muslims, the Egyptian news portal Ahram Online reported.

Among films and plays targeted by the lawyer were the movie “Morgan Ahmed Morgan” and the play “Al-Zaeem” (“The Leader”), the report said.

Imam was also handed a fine of LE1,000 in absentia, the court document showed. He could not immediately be reached for comment.

Court cases against directors, actors, artists and intellectuals for failing to respect religious authority are common in Egypt. But the case against Imam is likely to draw attention due to his high profile and the timing of the verdict.

Egypt’s most successful movie star, Imam has been a box-office sell-out for much of his career. His more serious films have dealt with the rise the Islamist militancy and taken aim at incompetent government officials.

“I think the lawyer who filed the case against Imam is taking advantage of the current circumstances with Islamists gaining power in Egypt,” said Nabil Abdel Fattah, an analyst and researcher at Al-Ahram Centre for Political and Strategic Studies in Cairo.

He said the sentence had likely been handed down because Imam had failed to appear in court, and expected it to be overturned on appeal.

Egyptian telecom tycoon and political liberal Naguib Sawiris also faces trial on a charge of showing contempt for religion in a case brought by another Islamist lawyer. Sawiris, a prominent figure in Egypt’s Coptic Christian community, was accused of showing contempt by tweeting a cartoon seen as insulting to Islam.

©2012 Reuters / Egypt Indipendent

 
Leave a comment

Posted by on February 6, 2012 in Art as a matter of life

 

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Bahgory’s timeless revolution

Everything about George Bahgory recalls a lost time. The renowned Egyptian painter and caricaturist (sometimes referred to as the “Grandaddy of Egyptian Caricature”) has cultivated for himself the classic image of a 19th century Parisian painter; mustachioed, with a pointy beard, and a painterly hat at a jaunty angle. Bahgory seems to lead the romantic life of the intellectual observer, moving back and forth every half-year from Cairo, to Paris, to Cairo, and back.

The figures that haunt his artistic imagination are those of generations past; he is a follower of Picasso who worships Om Kalthoum, who once would share a downtown café table with Naguib Mahfouz. Bahgory lives in the grand tradition of the artist flâneur — the urban stroller, lounger and observer who, in his leisurely way, takes in the city as it buzzes about him, portraying the people of the urban tableau, full of lively cafés and bread sellers sailing through downtown alleyways. “I have a crowd in almost every painting,” Bahgory told Egypt Independent.

Bahgory spent 2011, as he has spent many of his years, painting downtown Cairo, where he lives and works when he is not in Paris. This past year, of course, the streets often fell into a different kind of chaos from the everyday jumble of shops and people and dust and traffic, chaos less conducive to contemplative observation. But Bahgory kept an attentive eye on this upheaval. “It was very interesting to find my people shouting,” he says, “I sleep hearing their voices.”

“Bahgory on Revolution,” a collection of these latest works, is currently on display at the Masar Gallery in Zamalek, timed to coincide with the one-year anniversary of the 25 January revolution.

Bahgory’s Cairo is colorful and romantic. It is hard to pin a time on the people and places that fill his vibrant depictions, which flatten out and twist dimensions in the Cubist style of his idol Pablo Picasso. Though Bahgory’s most recent work takes on the most overwhelming and present subject of the contemporary moment, he still works with timeless imagery, choosing cafes, camels and street musicians as his emblems of upheaval, along with flashes of the obligatory Egyptian flag.

Bahgory’s speedy drawing style (“I don’t like discipline,” he says) is fitting for depiction of the heaving masses of Tahrir Square. On less violent days of the uprising, the 80-year-old artist spent time in the square sketching, and still goes from time to time. But the event that he devotes the most canvas to in “Bahgory on Revolution” took place on one of the most violent and notorious of the 18 days. The Battle of the Camels features in the pair of pieces “Battle of the Camels I & II” as well as in the grand, wall-sized canvas “The True Path (Tahrir Square).”

The latter work exemplifies how painting, typically a medium of high art and slow response, can capture the movement and emotion of even a familiar and contemporary moment more effectively than straightforward photography. Bahgory’s wild canvas layers paper and fabric over a writhing crowd, a thick mass of drawing and collage, in which a flailing horse and camel fall headlong into the teaming, wailing sea of people. The piece evokes the terror and absurdity of that infamous day more effectively than most of the more documentary representations that have been in such ample supply in recent months.

The subject of revolution often drums up strong iconography and bombastic feeling in artists who choose to represent it. Though in a recent interview with Ahram Weekly, Bahgory cited “Guernica,” Picasso’s gut-wrenching series of drawings on the Spanish Civil War, as an inspiration for his work on the revolution in Egypt, the sketches and paintings at Masar are much more joyful and triumphant than that earlier, more tragic collection. Despite the panic apparent in “The True Path (Tahrir Square),” its title imbues it with revolutionary grandeur, and the collection also includes the seemingly requisite ode to nationalism “Proud Egyptian,” a collaged portrait of a voluptuous, haloed woman in peasant dress, the accents of her clothes taken from fabric featuring a distinctively Egyptian pattern.

While “Guernica” was a project in documenting suffering, Bahgory’s revolutionary paintings serve more to glorify than to mourn, and so veer away from tragedy toward imagery of populist triumph. Still, Bahgory’s is an honest emotional response that channels and amplifies the energy of those early revolutionary days more effectively than much other work produced in response to the same events.

Bahgory writes in his text for the exhibition, “My own screams have become the canvases that you see in this exhibition.” But despite its emotional strength, all his work is steeped in nostalgia. “Bahgory on Revolution” includes a room of portraits in Bahgory’s signature painted style, walking a fine line between expressive abstraction and pure caricature. The selection includes two new portraits of Om Kalthoum, long a favorite subject of the painter, and a portrait of Sheikh Imam, the legendary singer whose late 1960s revolution-themed songs have seen a revival in the context of this current revolutionary moment. Bahgory cannot let go of those looming icons of the past. But even when he paints the violent, triumphant, tumultuous Cairo of 2011, what emerges on the canvas is a timeless Egypt, of camels, horses, shisha and peasant-dress, where signs of modernity — of 2011 — are almost completely absent. Still, Bahgory’s colors vibrate on the canvas, and I believe him when he says, “My five fingers have turned to hot red, orange and yellow… mirroring the flames around me.”

“Bahgory on Revolution” will be on view at Al Masar Gallery, Baehler’s Mansion, 157B, 26 July Street, Zamalek, Cairo, until 7 February. The gallery is open from 11:00 am to 9:00 pm, Saturday through Thursday.

©2012 Egypt Indipendent

 
Leave a comment

Posted by on February 1, 2012 in Uncategorized

 

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

‘Songs for Tahrir’: Music for and from liberation

Most times that Palestinian artist and musician Reem Kelani was in Tahrir Square, she took her tape recorder along. She weaves some of these recordings into her radio piece “Songs for Tahrir.”

The focus is on song and music, and alongside the new musical sounds of a young generation — music such as the collective compositions of the Choir Project and Ramy Essam’s music drawn from people’s slogans — she hears the sounds of old pioneers: Sayyed Darwish, Sheikh Imam and Abdel Halim Hafez, among others. She was particularly excited to find the music of Darwish, a man whose music she has been researching for the past eight years, at the heart of mass protests in 2011. She describes Darwish as a “composer, revolutionary, man of the people.”

The narrative that Kelani creates is both unobtrusive and essential. She gives a sense of the revolution as ongoing, a sense of music as integral to protest. She captures the creativity, spontaneity and potency of protest not just during the 18 days in January, 2011 that led to former President Mubarak’s fall, but also in November when the security and military forces attacked protesters in Tahrir Square.

Songs old and new, powerful chants and slogans and ambulance sirens against the backdrop of chants of “freedom, freedom” come together to create a full and rich soundscape of resistance. And as Salam Yousry of the Choir Project says, some of the best music of the revolution came from people who we don’t even know. The Choir Project’s work involves collective composition, incorporating the perspectives and experiences of many. In a stirring clip from their concert just days after Mubarak’s fall, we hear, “Might, strong will and faith, Egypt’s revolution is everywhere.”

Kelani does not promise an objective or comprehensive account of the music of the revolution — which would, of course, be impossible. Rather, she delivers a sensitive, subjective and insightful exploration of music and protest in today’s Egypt, an optimistic one that observes the present and is informed by the history of subversive music in Egypt. Having participated in the initial 18-day uprising, she returned in November — coincidentally on the day that five days of street fights between protesters and security forces began — and interviewed several of the activists, poets and musicians she had met in Tahrir Square earlier in the year. She unabashedly focuses on Darwish, a man whose music the regime either ignored or exploited and whose songs found a rightful home on the streets of Egypt in 2011.

Darwish lived and worked in working-class neighborhoods. The sounds and intonations he heard around him, Kelani explains, went into his songs, many of which were written for the oppressed and marginalized. And in this way, his music was both from and for the people. Kelani takes her tape recorder with her away from Tahrir Square, and records the kinds of sounds that Darwish would have heard and incorporated into his music. From the sound of market-sellers calling out their produce to the ubiquitous and nasal tones of “bikya, bikya” of those who buy and sell on the street, Kelani offers a soundscape of Cairo that complements and informs the soundscape of revolution.

She tells us about one of Darwish’s songs — on the surface about dates, but actually in praise of the nationalist anti-colonial leader Saad Zaghloul. She sings the opening lines, and in a beautiful moment, the date seller she is talking to takes up the song. The music of Darwish was rooted in the struggle against colonialism, and Khaled Abol Naga, the lead actor in “Microphone,” a film about the alternative music and art scene in Alexandria, says that if we compare the attitude the regime held toward the people with that of colonial powers, you can see why his lyrics resonate again.

The music of Darwish that was sung in Tahrir Square encompassed political and love songs, and also a song of love for the homeland, the Egyptian national anthem, “Biladi, biladi” (Oh, my Country), the words of which come from a speech by anti-colonial leader Mostafa Kamel — a speech that inspired the teenage Darwish to write it. After signing peace with Israel, the regime did not want to continue using a national anthem glorifying military struggle, and so it went back to the iconic anthem of 1919. In this way, a regime subservient to Western interests neutralized the anti-establishment and anti-colonial ethos of Darwish and the national anthem itself. Sung by thousands and millions in 2011 facing the security forces of that same regime, the song’s potency was renewed and reinvigorated.

Samia Jaheen, from the band Eskendrella, talks about performing a Darwish song before the revolution. The band has been working together for years, composing their own music, as well as songs from old greats such as Darwish, Sheikh Emam and poems by Saleh Jaheen and Fouad Haddad. They are activists, and throughout 2011 have performed at protest after protest. Samia says that when the band performed Darwish’s “Remember Egypt is still beautiful” before the revolution, they were accused of chauvinism. Many responded by saying, “We Egyptians have so many problems…We are dirty, rude, poor, and uncivilized.” But, Jaheen argues, “We need to unite to believe in ourselves, and that’s how we will become better. We will not become the best we can be by insulting each other.”

Kelani’s stands out for putting art and music into a context that includes all kinds of resistance and political discussion. It collapses artificial distinctions between art and politics, as she describes the way singing sustained protest. Interweaving the sounds of Cairo’s streets with chants and song, she gives music a privileged place not apart from the ordinary, but emerging from and returning to the daily sounds that make up our lives. While recognizing the novelty and creativity of much of the music, she simultaneously ties it to music from the past that also emerged from a collective rage. And as one slogan chanted on the country’s streets proclaims, “The rage of Egyptians is a dangerous thing” — for those in power, of course.

©2012 Al-Masry Al-Youm

 
Leave a comment

Posted by on January 27, 2012 in Uncategorized

 

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Festival : The Victory of Libyan Revolution

THE Ministry of Culture, Arts and Heritage will organise a festival titled ‘The Victory of Libyan Revolution’ at the Qatar National Theatre on Thursday and Friday. The festival, which is titled ‘The Victory of the Libyan Revolution’, will feature prominent Libyan artistes, writers and popular poets.

The event is the third in a series to be organised by the ministry, after the festival of the poets to celebrate the victory of the revolutions in Egypt and Tunisia. The festival will include an operetta titled ‘One million thanks to His Highness the Emir’ on the first day.

The operetta, which will be performed by Libyan children, expresses Libyans’ gratitude to the Emir His Highness Sheikh Hamad bin Khalifa al Thani as well as a special tribute to Al Jazeera cameraman Ali Hassan al Jabir. Speaking at a press conference to highlight the objectives of the event, Director of Culture and Arts Department at ministry Faleh Ajlan al Hajiri praised the role played of artistes in the Arab spring, which started from Tunisia. He gave the list of participants and activities of the two-day event.

He said that there would be a sustainable partnership between Libya and Qatar in the various field related to art and culture. Hajiri lauded Libyan people for their efforts in ousting the old regime. Qatari singer Ali Abd al Sattar, in collaboration with the Libyan singer Ayman Al Hawni, has prepared two songs. The first song is titled ‘Thank you dear, without you there would be no freedom; there would be no unity’.

It will be led by a chorus of children coming from Libya. The song is dedicated to the Libyan people and the victorious revolution. The second song entitled ‘The Martyr’ is dedicated to those who died during the struggle for freedom.

Prominent artistes to perform at the festival include Libyan singers Jilani, Asmae Saleem and Youssef al Shaybani, Qatari singer Ali Abd al Sattar, poets Saad al Amrouni, Ali al Shahhat, Anouar al Shaghiri and Abdul Qadir Bouhadma.

 
2 Comments

Posted by on December 2, 2011 in Art as a matter of life

 

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 279 other followers